Permanent Marker Showdown: Which Marker Is the Blackest?

We held a showdown to find the blackest permanent marker, a competition focused solely on the intensity of black ink.

Permanent markers are a staple in everyday life. They dry quickly and can be used on various surfaces, making them indispensable stationery items. Among them, black permanent markers are especially common, with most people likely having at least one on hand.

There are many different black permanent markers available from various companies, making it hard to know which to choose. While researching markers, we came across a ranking article by MONOQLO titled "Top 8 Recommended Permanent Markers of 2023 – Unfading Black Pens Thoroughly Tested!" The MONOQLO article evaluated markers based on two criteria: resistance to fading once dry and usability on different surfaces. However, it did not assess the actual blackness of the ink.

That gap inspired a new test: a contest to find the blackest permanent marker, judged specifically on blackness.

Contestants: Meet the Competitors in the Blackest Marker Showdown

We selected the following eight markers from Japanese and international brands for the blackness comparison:

• Teranishi Chemical "Magic Ink ML-T1 Black"
  Japan's first permanent marker. A household name in Japan, and no black marker showdown would be complete without it.
• Pilot "Twin Marker – Bullet Tip"
  Ranked No.1 in the MONOQLO article for usability. But how will it fare in terms of blackness?
• Mitsubishi Pencil "Peace Marker PA152TR.24"
  From the maker of the Guinness-certified Uni-ball One gel pen known for its ultra-dark black ink. Will its permanent marker hold up?
• Sakura Color Products "My Name Twin"
  A classic for labeling school shoes and supplies, familiar to many from childhood.
• Zebra "Mackee Pro DX YYSS10-BK"
  Ranked lowest in the MONOQLO usability test. Can it redeem itself in the blackness category?
• Tamiya "Paint Marker XF-1 Flat Black"
  From the model kit brand Tamiya. One of the few markers with a matte finish.
• Sharpie "Sharpie Permanent Marker"
  The go-to permanent marker in the U.S. A head-to-head between Japan and the U.S. begins.
• Holts "Color Pen"
  A matte black pen from the British brand Holts. Tamiya's main matte rival.

A total of eight permanent markers were evaluated in this blackness showdown.

How Was the Blackness Measured?

We tested each marker on business-card-sized matte paper, applying two layers in a cross pattern to ensure full coverage.

Using a measuring device, we determined the average reflectance between 400nm and 700nm, then calculated the light absorption rate from it. A higher absorption rate indicates a blacker ink.

Results

Here are the top three blackest markers:

• 1st Place: Tamiya "Paint Marker XF-1 Flat Black"
• 2nd Place: Holts "Color Pen"
• 3rd Place: Teranishi Chemical "Magic Ink ML-T1 Black"

Tamiya's marker achieved a light absorption rate of 97.3%, far surpassing the others, most of which were below 95%. Its matte finish proved to be a major factor, showing the true power of low reflectivity.

Holts' Color Pen took second place, representing the strength of a century-old British company.

Teranishi's Magic Ink came in third. As Japan's original permanent marker, it remains an impressive option, especially for those wanting a super-black, easy-to-use pen.

Summary

In this contest to find the blackest permanent marker, Tamiya's Paint Marker XF-1 Flat Black took a commanding lead. Writing on black construction paper with this marker still produced clear, visible letters, an impressive display of contrast.

Unfortunately, at the time of testing this standout product appeared to be out of stock on Tamiya's website and Amazon, though some hobby retailers still list it. A shame, given its incredible blackness. A restock from Tamiya would surely be welcomed.

A Final Note

To close the blackness showdown, another contestant takes on the challenge. While Tamiya's marker had an impressive 97.3% light absorption, our water-based acrylic paint called "Musou Black Paint" achieves a more extreme blackness. When airbrushed, it reaches up to 99.4% light absorption, and even with a normal brush, it achieves up to 98.9%, maintaining ultra-low reflectivity.

"Musou Black Paint" is available on our store in 100ml and 1L bottles, a 15L can, and bulk sets. We also offer a painting service.

For anyone seeking a new level of blackness, our paint will offer an entirely different dimension.

That is all for this blog. See you in the next one!